[I had sent the tweet above out with the wrong picture for the caption before correcting it.]Family and friends attend the burial of 3-month-old Kleiver Enrique Hernndez at the cemetery in Ca, Venezuela, Aug. 17, 2017. [wrong pix b4]@BootsRiley Is this picture staged? Are those tears faked? Is that coffin empty?https://t.co/tUytd99aBD pic.twitter.com/gQosjweJHW— Clay Claiborne (@clayclai) March 1, 2019
Nerio Parra and Abigail Torres on July 8, 2017, visit the graves of two of their five children who died from severe malnutrition, in Caracas, Venezuela.@BootsRiley Was this picture staged? Are these graves empty?https://t.co/tUytd9qM0d pic.twitter.com/oUg7A5lu0U— Clay Claiborne (@clayclai) March 1, 2019
Oil prices falling hurt all OPEC countries but only in Venezula was there mass starvation and a 90% poverty rate -- tell me how that isn't Maduro's fault. https://t.co/KvyzaWFpV4— pplswar (@pplswar) March 2, 2019
That is not good evidence to claim it being faked.— الياس ابو جودة (@LyesAbouJaoude) March 4, 2019
He probably threw it away because he didn't like it. You don't need to eat anything you find. Especially not on the spot.
Unblock @clayclai who actually gave you enough arguments before you decided to ignore him
That's the perfect evidence. He didnt eat the food there or later, and had NEVER eaten it before and says he has a home. He did it to make a statement.— Boots Riley (@BootsRiley) March 4, 2019
The claycai dude tried to say that ppl lay out food in garbage trucks to get to the bottom!!! Not a serious person. Ridiculous.
And the reason it had to be staged? Can you speak to that? Is it because everybody is well fed in Venezuela so pictures like one below, or in the video have to be staged? How did they stage this picture: pic.twitter.com/Z3NljArEAN— Clay Claiborne (@clayclai) March 4, 2019
Give a search to this picture. First published as being from the congo in 2016 by Gestion. but used by opposition and msm now as being in VZ. Yes- manufacturing consent.— Boots Riley (@BootsRiley) March 4, 2019
@pplswar replied to @BootsRiley:
I searched the image -- all 5 uses in 2016 indicate this is Venezuela. pic.twitter.com/USia0Az2Wt— pplswar (@pplswar) March 4, 2019
— Boots Riley (@BootsRiley) March 4, 2019
Not one Congolese source backs Riley's photo claim. Not. One.— pplswar (@pplswar) March 5, 2019
I have to admit that I picked that photo from a Google search for starving in Venezuela because didn't want to keep recycling the photos I used in the blog post, which were well vetted. That was a mistake. /1— Clay Claiborne (@clayclai) March 5, 2019
If the picture I used was what you claim, really from the Congo, published 24.07.2016 - 05:50 A.M, then that would really be a problem because Google is all over the place claiming it is "starving children venezuela" like this search: https://t.co/nmGPZjSl5O /2— Clay Claiborne (@clayclai) March 5, 2019
It does happen all too often that a picture is taken from 1 atrocity to falsely represent another one and that should be challenged where ever it is found. For example, do an image search on this photo & you will find it widely cited as from Iraq war or ISIS /3 pic.twitter.com/BFfdpJQenR— Clay Claiborne (@clayclai) March 5, 2019
But this little girl was beheaded by Bashar al Assad's artillery in Syria. I know because I had used it in my blog in 2012. Later I wrote this post demanding that Google correct the record {they haven't - Surprise, Surprise!} https://t.co/U9PYV5uRE4— Clay Claiborne (@clayclai) March 5, 2019
In the present case, if you really believe that photo is from the Congo and not Venezuela, then you really have bigger fish to fry than blocking me on twitter, you need to demand that Google stop mislabeling that photo. Maybe with ur celeb status, you may have better luck /5— Clay Claiborne (@clayclai) March 5, 2019
But I really doubt it because this is an old photo dating from at least Oct. 11, 2015, Venezuelans have been hungry for a while. https://t.co/s9FMlwT3ig— Clay Claiborne (@clayclai) March 5, 2019
If someone told you this photo originated from the Congo in 2016, then I'm afraid you are the one that got duped @BootsRiley pic.twitter.com/YwaZl5eGlj
Gestio credit it to another Peruvian paper, RRP, and this source shows it is a lot older than the Gestion publication, so either way this is pretty definitively settled as not DRC, and anyone still arguing it is looks pretty foolish to me.— Bob From Brockley (@bobfrombrockley) March 5, 2019
And so it goes in TwitterLand.
NYT has a picture of people foraging at a garbage site from 2017https://t.co/YoLT9r2u9N— الياس ابو جودة (@LyesAbouJaoude) March 5, 2019
Syria is the Paris Commune of the 21st Century!
No comments:
Post a Comment